Addressing Workplace Discrimination Claims: A Guide for Employers

Boodell & Domanskis, LLC
Male colleagues whispering behind sad women in office

At Boodell & Domanskis, LLC, we understand the challenges employers face when addressing workplace discrimination claims. Illinois law, including the Illinois Human Rights Act (IHRA), sets clear standards for maintaining a discrimination-free workplace. 

As a firm practicing employer law, we guide businesses through the legal requirements and practical steps needed to handle these claims effectively. Let’s take a look at key considerations under Illinois employer law, offering employers a clear path to respond to allegations while staying compliant with state regulations.

Discrimination Under Illinois Employer Law

Illinois employer law prohibits discrimination based on protected characteristics such as race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability, marital status, sexual orientation, gender identity, and military status, as outlined in the IHRA. 

The Illinois Department of Human Rights (IDHR) enforces these protections, investigating claims filed by employees who believe they have faced unlawful treatment. As employers, we must recognize that discrimination claims can arise from various workplace actions, including hiring, promotions, terminations, or day-to-day interactions.

Under employer law in Illinois, discrimination can take the form of disparate treatment, where an employee is treated differently because of a protected characteristic, or disparate impact, where a policy unintentionally harms a protected group. 

For example, a hiring practice that disproportionately excludes older workers could trigger a claim, even if unintentional. Our firm emphasizes the importance of understanding these distinctions to address claims promptly and in accordance with employer law.

Responding to a Discrimination Claim

When an employee files a discrimination claim with the IDHR, employers receive a formal notice detailing the allegations. Illinois employer law requires a timely response, typically within 60 days, to avoid default judgments. 

At Boodell & Domanskis, LLC, we advise employers to take immediate action by gathering relevant documents, such as personnel files, performance reviews, and communication records, to build a strong defense.

The IDHR’s process begins with an investigation, which may include interviews, document requests, and a fact-finding conference. Employer law in Illinois allows us to represent our clients during these proceedings, presenting evidence to counter the allegations. 

If the IDHR finds substantial evidence of discrimination, the case may proceed to a hearing before the Illinois Human Rights Commission (IHRC) or be resolved through mediation. Our approach under employer law focuses on preparing a thorough response to protect our clients’ interests at every stage.

Developing a Proactive Workplace Policy

A well-crafted anti-discrimination policy is a cornerstone of compliance with Illinois employer law. We recommend that employers create clear, written policies that define prohibited conduct, outline reporting procedures, and detail consequences for violations. 

These policies should be communicated to all employees through handbooks and regular training sessions to promote a workplace culture that aligns with employer law standards.

Training is particularly critical under Illinois employer law. The IHRA mandates annual sexual harassment prevention training for all employees, but we encourage broader training on all forms of discrimination. 

By educating supervisors and staff, employers can reduce the risk of claims and demonstrate a commitment to compliance with employer law. Our firm assists clients in drafting policies and conducting training tailored to their specific needs, assuring alignment with Illinois regulations.

Investigating Internal Complaints

When an employee raises a discrimination concern internally, Illinois employer law requires employers to respond promptly and impartially. 

We advise our clients to establish a consistent investigation process to address these complaints before they escalate to the IDHR. This involves designating a neutral investigator, such as an HR professional or external consultant, to review the allegations.

During an investigation, employers should interview the complainant, the accused, and any witnesses while collecting relevant evidence. Illinois employer law emphasizes maintaining confidentiality to the extent possible and protecting employees from retaliation. 

After completing the investigation, we recommend documenting findings and taking appropriate action, whether that involves disciplinary measures or policy changes. Our firm guides employers through this process to maintain compliance with employer law and minimize legal risks.

Key Steps to Mitigate Discrimination Risks

To help employers stay ahead of discrimination claims, we have outlined five practical steps that align with Illinois employer law:

  • Implement clear policies: Develop and distribute an anti-discrimination policy that complies with the IHRA and is accessible to all employees.

  • Conduct regular training: Provide annual training on discrimination and harassment, covering all protected characteristics under Illinois employer law.

  • Maintain documentation: Keep detailed records of employee performance, disciplinary actions, and policy acknowledgments to support your defense in a claim.

  • Respond promptly to complaints: Address internal complaints quickly and thoroughly, following a structured investigation process as required by employer law.

  • Monitor workplace culture: Regularly assess your workplace environment through surveys or feedback to identify and address potential issues early.

By following these steps, employers can reduce the likelihood of claims and demonstrate compliance with Illinois employer law. Our firm stands ready to assist in implementing these measures to protect your business.

Defending Against Claims in Court

If a discrimination claim progresses beyond the IDHR, it may result in litigation in state or federal court. Illinois employer law allows employees to file lawsuits under the IHRA or federal laws like Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, depending on the circumstances. 

At Boodell & Domanskis, LLC, we represent employers in these proceedings, leveraging our knowledge of employer law to build a robust defense.

Court cases often involve discovery, where both parties exchange evidence, followed by motions or a trial. We work to limit our clients’ liability by challenging the claimant’s evidence, demonstrating compliance with employer law, or negotiating settlements when appropriate. 

Illinois employer law also permits recovery of attorneys’ fees in some cases if the claim is deemed frivolous, which we pursue when warranted.

Addressing Retaliation Concerns

Retaliation claims are a significant risk under Illinois employer law, as the IHRA protects employees who report discrimination or participate in investigations. 

Retaliation can include actions like demotions, terminations, or hostile treatment following a complaint. We counsel employers to avoid any adverse actions against employees who engage in protected activities, as these can lead to separate claims.

To mitigate retaliation risks, we recommend documenting legitimate business reasons for any employment decisions, such as performance-based terminations. Training supervisors on retaliation prohibitions under Illinois employer law is also critical. 

Our firm helps employers develop strategies to address these concerns while maintaining compliance with employer law.

Leveraging Mediation and Settlement

Mediation offers a valuable opportunity to resolve discrimination claims without the time and cost of litigation. 

Under Illinois employer law, the IDHR encourages mediation early in the process, allowing both parties to reach a mutually agreeable solution. We represent employers in these discussions, advocating for fair terms that align with their interests.

Settlements may involve monetary payments, policy changes, or other remedies. Our firm evaluates the strengths and weaknesses of each case to determine whether settlement is advisable under Illinois employer law. 

By pursuing mediation when appropriate, we help employers resolve disputes efficiently while minimizing disruption to their operations.

Staying Compliant with Evolving Employer Law

Illinois employer law is subject to change through new legislation, court rulings, or IDHR guidance. For example, recent amendments to the IHRA have expanded protections for gender identity and clarified training requirements. We stay informed of these developments to keep our clients compliant with current employer law standards.

To maintain compliance, we encourage employers to review their policies annually and consult with legal counsel when facing new challenges. Our firm provides ongoing support, from policy updates to representation in claims, to help employers address discrimination issues under Illinois employer law.

The Next Steps

At Boodell & Domanskis, LLC, we partner with employers to develop policies, investigate complaints, and defend against claims while maintaining compliance with the IHRA and other regulations. We’re proud to serve Chicago, Illinois, and the surrounding areas. Call today.